The Weightings


Ashley Denny Petch


#85. The smell of concrete after rain” 

This is my favourite entry from Michael Sorkin’s immensely satisfying list  ‘250 things an architect should know’. It’s my favourite because I too love to romanticize concrete. Let me tell you why. 

Concrete is a magical material. It’s durable and strong and versatile. It’s expressive. Concrete is made from sand. It’s porous. It’s important to be porous. Concrete is the only building material that starts off as a liquid. It can be shaped and molded. And most importantly, it retains memory. It absorbs rain and releases the smell of earth, hence Sorkin’s recommendation. 

The Barbican Conservatory. Fallingwater. Christ the Redeemer. The Guggenheim. Imagine how these smell after the rain. Our world comes alive in concrete. 


#70. Shear and moment

But like all of God’s creatures, concrete is fallible. It refuses to stretch. It adores being compressed but it can’t handle being pulled apart. Little cracks appear and soon after it collapses. 

Architects and engineers have long-solved this problem by giving concrete an elastic, high-tensile buddy named steel. Steel is very stretchy meaning that it can be pulled or bent without breaking. For years and years, these architects and engineers have embedded steel bars directly into the concrete and thus, created composite material that handles the weight and bendiness. Now you are ready to build the Sydney Opera House, Habitat 67, the Hoover Dam. 


#171. The view from the Acropolis.

Of course, concrete is an ancient material. But the ancient Greeks, with their ungodly amount of quarries, had little use for it. They were drowning in marble. It was the Romans who developed concrete on the massive scale that allowed them to make the Pantheon, their aqueducts and bridges.  

Modern Greeks, however, it’s fair to say are deeply acquainted with concrete, as a building material and a way of life. Athens is famously a sea of polykatoikias. And not just in the cities. In small towns and villages as well, concrete abounds. 
If you’re driving in Greece, let’s say from Thiva to Trikala, and you happen to look out the window, what do you see? Slow down. Try to look past the roadside shrines and olive groves.  

You see a house made of concrete. But this is not a normal house. It’s missing its top half. It’s waiting for a lid, the only thing we can see are the protruding steel bars facing upwards and standing at attention, expectant.  You see one house like this and then another, and then more. 

Ok, keep your eyes on the road! You don’t want to end up a shrine on the highway, do you?

#190. Strengths of materials (if only intuitively).

These steel bars are called anamones (αναμονές). Construction-wise, they maintain the structural continuity of the house so that extra floors can be added later using a concrete slab called a plaka. The bars are made of steel (rebar), which keeps the concrete from cracking - eventually, when a new floor is added, they’ll be encased inside the newly poured concrete. 

In Greek, the word anamoni translates to "waiting" or "standby." Anamones is the plural: the waitings. A man from Karditsa once told me that this is what locals call these unfinished structures scattered across the landscape. I think that’s beautiful. 

 So why are these houses left like this? Why leave the top floor unfinished, open to the elements and waiting?

 

#102.  Many ideas about what constitutes utopia.

There is a persistent urban legend that homes are built like this to cheat the tax codes—that residents don’t have to pay property taxes on "unfinished" buildings, so they leave them exposed on purpose. And while it’s true that an unplastered shell with no electricity gets a heavy tax discount in Greece, most rebar is less about dodging the state and more about pausing until the next child, or the next paycheck, arrives. The main reason is familial: these homes are built to expand as the family grows. 

It goes like this: your parents have a plot of family land. They build their house and reserve the promise of a second floor for YOU, the daughter, for when you grow up, get married, and start a family. Then another floor gets added when YOUR daughter gets married - and it’s chelonas all the way down. Or up, I should say.

Until the PASOK government under Andreas Papandreou formally abolished the mandatory legal dowry system in 1983, providing shelter for a daughter was an urgent social imperative. Traditionally, parents were expected to provide not just linens or jewelry, but a home. The groom provided the income; the bride’s family provided the shelter. Building upward on existing foundations was the most economically viable way for working-class families to fulfill this heavy obligation.


#72. How the crow flies.

But what if you were blessed with a stinky family of only boys? Well then, no matter. Perhaps the ground floor would be reserved for the eldest son, and the floors above for the younger sons. Alternatively, you could pour the plaka, the concrete slab and expose some rebar on both sides and in a line down the middle, to signal that each son gets half the plot to build upward. 

But what if the prodigal son or prudent daughter flees Greece? The anamones stay, built strongly enough to send a message all the way across an ocean. You have a place to come back to. You own a piece of the sky here. Don’t tarry. Come back and you can start your real life. 

There are other reasons of course. A grandma needs to be moved in. A cousin, an uncle. It’s not prescriptive. In all cases, the concrete is left unfinished because someone loves a person who may one day need it. An expression of generosity, but also an expression of expectation. 


#92. Sentence structure

Back to the waitings. Ana-mones.

Mones, Moni in Greek is to ‘stay’, to ‘abide’, to ‘dwell’. Meno stin Athina. I live [stay] in Athens.

Out of moni, we get the words Monastery (a place of abiding) and Monk, and from its latin cousin manseio, we get Mansion, Maison and Manor. From there, we get remnant [re- (back) + manēre (to stay). Literally: To stay behind] and permanent [per- (through) + manēre (to stay). Literally: To stay through to the very end].

It’s a rich root to feed on - what does it mean to abide, to stay, to dwell?  


  1. Ana means to go up, to repeat. Ana+moni: We abide, we stay upwards. to wait. 

  2. Ypo means under. Ypo-moni: We bear under the abiding. We endure. We are patient.

  3. Epi means upon. Epi-moni: We stay upon. We persist. We insist. 

  4. Para means next to. Para-moni.  We stay beside. We stand on the threshold of what's next. The eve.

  5. Pros means toward. Pros-moni. We go toward the place where we’ll stay. We yearn. The anticipation of a wish fulfilled.

Όλα αυτά — παραμονή, υπομονή, επιμονή, προσμονή, υπάρχουν για τις αναμονές.

Where we live, how we wait, what we endure. In five prefixes, we understand how a language quietly maps the boundaries of home, expectation, and desire. 


#83. Accidents must happen.

Waiting is an existential condition. It forces us to confront uncertainty and mark time, however we choose to measure it.

Henri Bergson, famed French philosopher and nemesis of Albert Einstein, believed time couldn't be understood by math or science alone. He distinguished between rigid clock-time and durée

(duration): the unpredictable flow of time as we actually experience it. Scientific time doesn't endure; it’s the inner life of a human being that acts as a true unit of duration. 

In L'Évolution créatrice, Bergson introduced the élan vital, which he defines as an inherent, spiritual life force driving all organisms to grow and evolve. As Bergson put it: “To exist is to change, to change is to mature, and to mature is to go on endlessly creating oneself.” I like to think of it as entropy’s friendly opposite.

The élan vital is the necessary, unpredictable movement of your life. It is the very force that reacts against what the anamones are built for. How can you change, mature, and endlessly create yourself if you aren't allowed to leave? Your family builds a concrete monument to stall the élan vital - to force life in a specific, predictable direction. You will come back. You will marry. This patch of earth is where you belong. They tether you to Karditsa. Grow upwards only.

For Bergson, true living meant placing oneself inside duration, experiencing freedom as constant movement. I would have loved to play Boggle with him. 

#132. Fear.

No one is happy about this, least of all me, but it’s time to talk about Heidegger. This is because he made a vital distinction between Erwarten and Warten. Erwarten is inauthentic time: expectation. It treats the future as an object to be secured, a calculated event. Warten, by contrast, is waiting in a pure state of being: allowing the future to unfold as it will.

Heidegger tells us to “Wait, but never expect”

If Heidegger had been a Greek villager, he would tell us that these anamones don't wait; they await. They cannot simply Warten because they have been lovingly poured with an embedded Erwarten.

I imagine Heidegger would want to play Risk with Bergson and me. We would politely decline, for obvious reasons.


#147.  The idea of too far.

We are perpetually er-waiting. For something better. For something new to happen. For a break. For more money. For a daughter to change her mind. To stay put. To make a home where you were forced to. What good is a dowry if you can’t see it standing there, waiting in the sky?

At my most uncharitable, I think of anamones as part of a long tradition of sad men building things for women to live in: Rapunzel’s tower, Daisy’s East Egg mansion, Danaë’s bronze chamber. An architectural trap laid with the best intentions is still a trap. 


#148.  The idea of too close.

Sometimes, here in Athens, when I’m cooking dinner, or having a drink with friends or walking alone, a spiky happiness strikes me, and I recognize it immediately as the relief of being far away. The pressure of constructing a life directly atop the foundations of those closest to me would have been volcanic. I couldn’t do it. I won’t! And besides, no one asked me to.

I’m still learning how to navigate the physical closeness that makes a family function here. My mother-in-law recently offered to travel across the country to stay with me during a minor surgery. My sister-in-law casually stroked my cheek because I stumbled through a joke in poorly spoken Greek. This embodied nearness makes me feel overwhelmed and deeply grateful in the exact same breath.

I think my anamones are facing downwards, or sideways. Or they're frayed. I don’t want anyone to wait on me to build something. I refuse to abide. 

 

#226. Concrete finishes.

What I haven’t said about the rebar is that it’s terminal. Pure concrete, left to its own devices, can last virtually forever - see the Pantheon or the Colosseum. The steel embedded inside that gives it tensile strength is susceptible to atmospheric betrayal. It corrodes. It expands, it reacts to seawater, to snow, to C02. It rusts, forcing the surrounding matrix outward until it breaks the concrete apart from within.

I don't think it’s too obvious to say that most humans struggle with uncertainty. We’re not built for it, physically or emotionally. The ancient Greeks had the oracle of Delphi. We have waiting rooms. But the Pythia never offered a blueprint - she offered riddles, left to interpretation. She understood that a guaranteed future is a contradiction in terms. To expect absolute certainty is to invite corrosion. 

Concrete left waiting too long destroys itself. We cannot escape the tragedy of the material.